Description
# CWA-2025-006: Improper error handling may lead to IBC channel opening despite error
**Severity**
High (Considerable + Likely)[^1]
**Affected versions:**
- wasmd 0.60.0
- wasmd >= 0.51.0 < 0.55.1
**Patched versions:**
- wasmd 0.60.1, 0.55.1, 0.54.1, 0.53.3
## Description of the bug
A contract erroring during IBC channel opening does not prevent the channel from opening.
## Applying the patch
The patch will be shipped in a wasmd release. You will also have to update `libwasmvm` if you build statically.
If you already use the latest / close to latest wasmd, you can update more or less as follows:
1. Check the current wasmd version: `go list -m github.com/CosmWasm/wasmd`
2. Bump the `github.com/CosmWasm/wasmd` dependency in your go.mod to 0.60.1 (Cosmos SDK 0.53 compatible), 0.55.1 (Cosmos SDK 0.50 compatible), 0.54.1 or 0.53.3; `go mod tidy`; commit.
3. If you use the static libraries `libwasmvm_muslc.aarch64.a`/`libwasmvm_muslc.x86_64.a`, make sure that you use the same version as your wasmvm version.
4. Check the updated wasmd version: `go list -m github.com/CosmWasm/wasmd` and ensure you see 0.60.1, 0.55.1, 0.54.1 or 0.53.3.
5. Follow your regular practices to deploy chain upgrades.
The patch is consensus breaking.
## Acknowledgement
This problem was discovered during an audit of the CosmWasm stack performed by Sherlock and funded by ICF/ICL in Q1 2025. Thank you for that work!
If you believe you have found a bug in the Interchain Stack or would like to contribute to the
program by reporting a bug, please see <https://hackerone.com/cosmos>.
## Timeline
- 2025-03-03: Auditor informs Confio about this issue.
- 2025-04-10: Confio developed the patch internally.
- 2025-06-05: Upcoming patch is announced.
- 2025-06-10: Patch is released.
[^1]: following Amulet's Severity Classification Framework ACMv1.2: <https://github.com/interchainio/security/blob/0295254e8645301ccb606d46108a45cede0a73e0/resources/CLASSIFICATION_MATRIX.md>
Affected packages
| Ecosystem | Package | Affected | Fixed | Record |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Go | github.com/CosmWasm/wasmd | >= 0.60.0, < 0.60.1 | 0.60.1 | GHSA-79xg-q4qm-7v9w |
| Go | github.com/CosmWasm/wasmd | >= 0.55.0, < 0.55.1 | 0.55.1 | GHSA-79xg-q4qm-7v9w |
| Go | github.com/CosmWasm/wasmd | >= 0.54.0, < 0.54.1 | 0.54.1 | GHSA-79xg-q4qm-7v9w |
| Go | github.com/CosmWasm/wasmd | >= 0.51.0, < 0.53.3 | 0.53.3 | GHSA-79xg-q4qm-7v9w |
| Go | github.com/CosmWasm/wasmd | >= 0.51.0, < 0.53.3 · >= 0.54.0, < 0.54.1 · >= 0.55.0, < 0.55.1 · >= 0.60.0, < 0.60.1 | 0.53.3, 0.54.1, 0.55.1, 0.60.1 | GO-2025-3755 |